Condition guide

How we grade condition

To give you a fast, accurate offer, we need an honest sense of your card's condition before it arrives. The grades below are what we use — both when you tell us how your card looks, and when our team checks it on arrival. Being accurate here means a faster, more reliable payout with no surprises later.

Mint

Corners are sharp with no visible wear, even under close inspection. The card is well-centered (roughly 55/45 or better, front and back). No scratches, print marks, or edge whitening. Original gloss/surface fully intact. Essentially looks as it did the day it was made.

Near Mint

Corners have only the slightest softness, visible only under close inspection or magnification — not noticeable at a glance. Minor off-centering is fine. Surface is clean with no more than negligible wear. No creases of any kind.

Excellent

Corner wear is visible to the naked eye, or there's light whitening on one or more corners. Some edge wear is present. May have very light surface scratches. Card is still perfectly flat — no creases or bends.

Good

Corners and edges show clear, noticeable wear. Surface may have visible scratches or scuffing. A light crease is acceptable at this grade, but the card must still be fully intact — not torn, split, or structurally compromised.

Poor

Heavy wear throughout, noticeable creasing, significant corner or edge damage, writing, stickers, stains, or any structural damage such as bends, tears, or water damage.